Methods, done simply

Task switching and what it costs

Every time you move from one task to another, your mind has to drop one set of rules and load another. In lab studies this costs a fraction of a second per switch, more for complex or unfamiliar tasks, and preparation shrinks the cost but never removes it. Small costs add up when you switch all day, and part of your attention stays on the task you left. The practical answer is fewer, cleaner switches, not willpower.

Coming soon to iPhone and iPad

Last checked

On this page

What a switch actually is

Every task runs on its own set of rules. Writing a report means one vocabulary, one goal and one set of files in your head; answering a supplier means another. Psychologists call this a task set. When you move from one to the other, your mind has to put down the first set and pick up the second, and that takes time.

In 2001, Joshua Rubinstein, David Meyer and Jeffrey Evans ran four experiments in which people either repeated one task or alternated between two, such as sorting shapes by different rules or doing different kinds of arithmetic. Alternating always cost time. The cost grew when the rules were more complex and shrank when there was a clear cue about which task came next. Switching into an unfamiliar task took longer than switching into a familiar one. They described two stages: deciding to change goals (“now this instead of that”), and loading the new rules.

Stephen Monsell’s 2003 review of the field reached the same core finding. Right after a switch, people are slower and usually make more errors. Giving them time to prepare reduces this switch cost, but does not remove it.

How big is the cost?

In the lab, small. The American Psychological Association’s summary of this research puts typical costs at a few tenths of a second per switch. The point is that they add up when switching is constant, and that the lab tasks are tiny compared with real work, where you also have to remember where you were.

You may have read that switching wastes 40% of your productive time. The source is a remark: the APA reports that Meyer “has said” brief mental blocks from shifting “can cost as much as 40 percent of someone’s productive time”. That is an expert’s upper estimate, not a measured average, so treat it as a ceiling, not a fact about your day.

The part that follows you: attention residue

The second cost is quieter. In 2009, Sophie Leroy found in two experiments that people find it hard to pull their attention away from an unfinished task, and they do worse on the next one as a result. She called the leftover attention residue. Finishing the first task was not always enough; finishing it under a bit of time pressure helped people let go of it.

A 2018 follow-up by Leroy and Theresa Glomb tested a fix. When people expected to return to interrupted work, a brief “ready-to-resume” plan, a moment noting where they were and what came next, reduced the residue and protected their performance on the interrupting task, across four studies.

What the evidence says and where it is weak

  • Solid: switch costs exist, grow with complexity, and survive preparation. This is one of the best-replicated findings in cognitive psychology.
  • Indirect: the jump from fractions of a second in the lab to hours lost at work is an inference. Real switches involve memory, motivation and other people, which lab tasks leave out.
  • Surprising: in a 2008 office-style study by Gloria Mark and colleagues, interrupted people finished their tasks as fast, with no loss of quality. The cost showed up elsewhere: more stress, frustration, time pressure and effort. Switching may cost you more in strain than in minutes.
  • Overstated: the 40% figure, and claims that switching “lowers your IQ”, go beyond what the research measured.

How to try it this week, on paper

  1. Count your switches for one morning. Keep a card beside you and make a tick each time you change what you are doing, including checking messages. Most people are surprised by the number. This is a baseline, not a score.
  2. Write a re-entry line before every planned switch. Before you leave a task, write one line: where you stopped and the next step (“drafting section 3, next: the budget table”). This is the ready-to-resume plan from the 2018 study, on paper.
  3. Group the small things. Put messages, calls and quick admin into two or three fixed slots instead of letting them interrupt. Task batching covers how.
  4. Protect one block for one thing. An hour, door closed, notifications off. Focus modes on the iPhone help with the notifications; a Pomodoro timer helps with the hour.
  5. Compare on Friday. Count switches again on one morning. Fewer ticks and a calmer head are both a result.

If whole kinds of work keep colliding, theme days group them by day instead of by hour, and deep work for normal jobs is about keeping one longer block for the hard thing.

Where Dozen helps, and where it doesn’t

Fewer switches start with one thing on screen at a time. Now is a quiet screen with a timer for the one to-do you started, also on the Lock Screen and in the Dynamic Island. A Live Activity appears only while you have a to-do running in Now. A New To-Do control for Control Center, the Lock Screen and the Action button opens Dozen on a new to-do in Today. That lets you jot down an interrupting thought without opening the task it belongs to.

Where it does not help: Dozen is not out yet, and a card on the desk does everything above. It cannot silence other apps; Focus modes in iOS do that. And Dozen does not block time on a calendar, so if you guard a focus hour, put it in your calendar too.

Questions and answers

Is multitasking a myth?

Doing two thinking tasks at the very same moment mostly turns into fast switching between them, and each switch has a cost. Pairing a thinking task with an automatic one, such as folding laundry while on a call, works far better.

Does switching tasks really waste 40% of your time?

That figure comes from a remark by the psychologist David Meyer, reported by the APA as 'can cost as much as' 40 percent. It is an upper estimate, not a measured average from a study. The lab results measure fractions of a second per switch.

How do I get back into a task after an interruption?

Before you leave it, write one line: where you stopped and the very next step. In experiments, a short plan like this reduced how much the unfinished task kept pulling at attention.

Sources

What this page says about Dozen was checked against the app on .

Last checked:

Get Dozen

Dozen is free to download. Dozen Pro, a monthly or yearly subscription, adds the Assistant.

Coming soon to iPhone and iPad

Dozen: Tasks & Notes

Dozen is free to download. Dozen Pro, a monthly or yearly subscription, adds the Assistant.

Coming soon to iPhone and iPad