Methods, done simply

SMART goals, and when they help

A SMART goal is specific, measurable, assignable (now usually "achievable"), realistic and time-bound. George T. Doran proposed the acronym in a two-page 1981 article for managers. The research behind it is really about goal setting in general: specific, challenging goals tend to beat "do your best". The acronym itself was never tested, and a 2022 review argues it can mislead, especially for health and exercise goals. Use it to turn a vague wish into a first step, not as a rule.

Coming soon to iPhone and iPad

Last checked

On this page

Where SMART comes from

In November 1981, George T. Doran wrote a short article in Management Review titled “There’s a S.M.A.R.T. way to write management’s goals and objectives”. It was written for managers setting objectives for their teams, and his five letters were:

  • Specific: aim at a particular area to improve.
  • Measurable: give a number, or at least an indicator of progress.
  • Assignable: say who will do it.
  • Realistic: what can be done with the resources at hand.
  • Time-related: say when it will be done.

Since then the letters have drifted. “Assignable” has mostly become “achievable”, “realistic” often becomes “relevant”, and some writers add extra letters (SMARTER, SMARTS). That drift matters: the acronym you meet today is not the one Doran wrote, and none of the versions came out of a study.

How to try it this week on paper

Pick one thing you keep meaning to do, and rewrite it on a card in four passes.

  1. Write the wish as it is. “Get fitter.” “Sort out the finances.” Do not polish it yet.
  2. Make it specific and measurable. What would you see if it happened? “Walk for 20 minutes on four days a week.” “Set up a direct debit for the three bills that keep surprising me.”
  3. Make it realistic for your actual week. Look at your diary. If four walks will not fit, write two. A goal you meet is better than a better goal you abandon.
  4. Give it a date and a first step. “By 30 November. First step: Monday after dropping the kids off, walk the long way back.” The first step is the part that changes what you do tomorrow.

Then keep the card where you will see it, and check it once a week, for example during your weekly review. If you missed, change the goal rather than scolding yourself: the research below says feedback is what makes goals work, and a missed week is feedback.

If step 4 feels like the useful bit, that is because it is a plan, not a goal. Our guide to if-then plans covers the best-tested way to write one.

What the evidence says, and where it is weak

What is solid

The research that SMART leans on is goal-setting theory, built over decades by Edwin Locke and Gary Latham. A 1981 review of laboratory and field studies found that specific, challenging goals led to higher performance more often than easy goals, “do your best” goals or no goals, with about 90% of studies showing positive or partly positive results. The same review listed the conditions: goals work best when people have the ability, get feedback on progress, and actually accept the goal. Locke and Latham’s 2002 summary of 35 years of work reached the same core conclusions and also set out the theory’s limits.

Where SMART departs from that research

Goal-setting theory says challenging. SMART says achievable or realistic. Those can pull in opposite directions, and the acronym does not say how to settle it.

In 2022, Christian Swann and colleagues reviewed how SMART goals are used to get people moving more. Their conclusion was blunt: the acronym is not based on scientific theory, is not consistent with the evidence, is applied inconsistently, has redundant criteria, is not used as Doran intended, and carries a risk of harm. For someone new to exercise, a specific, measurable target can turn into a pass-or-fail test they keep failing.

Goals can backfire

In 2009, Lisa Ordóñez and three co-authors argued that goals have side effects that advocates ignore: a narrow focus that neglects everything outside the goal, more risk-taking, more cheating to hit the number, less learning and less enjoyment. Locke and Latham replied in the same journal that the critique relied on anecdotes and selective citations. Both sides agree goals are powerful; they disagree about how often they go wrong. For a personal list, the practical lesson is modest: a number is a tool, and if hitting it starts to cost something you care about, change the number.

When SMART helps, and when it does not

  • Helps: a vague, recurring wish (“sort the garage”) that never turns into action; a goal you need to explain to someone else; anything with a real deadline.
  • Less helpful: something new where you cannot yet know what is realistic; a hobby that should stay fun; large life directions, where a list of what matters this year, as in our year-end review questions, is a better start.

For bigger, multi-month aims, see OKRs for your own life or the 12 Week Year.

Where Dozen helps, and where it doesn’t

A SMART goal ends in a date and a first step, and that part fits in any to-do list. A to-do can have a day to do it, a deadline and a repeat, each set from its own panel. A project can read as one thread of notes, tasks and what you finished. So the goal can live as a project, with the note explaining why it matters next to the steps.

Where it does not help: the measuring is yours to do: a tally on the card or a spreadsheet keeps the number. Dozen is not out yet, and an index card does this method well.

Questions and answers

What does SMART stand for?

Doran’s 1981 version was specific, measurable, assignable, realistic and time-related. Most modern versions use specific, measurable, achievable, relevant and time-bound. Neither version has more evidence behind it than the other.

Are SMART goals backed by research?

Goal setting is well researched, and specific, challenging goals tend to improve performance on a task. The SMART acronym itself was not derived from that research and has not been tested as a package.

When should I not use a SMART goal?

When you are new to something and do not know what is realistic yet, when the activity should stay enjoyable, or when hitting a number could tempt you to cut corners. A learning goal or an open goal ("see how far I can walk") can work better.

Sources

What this page says about Dozen was checked against the app on .

Last checked:

Get Dozen

Dozen is free to download. Dozen Pro, a monthly or yearly subscription, adds the Assistant.

Coming soon to iPhone and iPad

Dozen: Tasks & Notes

Dozen is free to download. Dozen Pro, a monthly or yearly subscription, adds the Assistant.

Coming soon to iPhone and iPad